The media is the problem

It occurred to me a few weeks ago that the media does a real disservice to American society in terms of our elections. I’d go so far as to say that next to money in politics, the media is the most damaging thing to our electoral and political processes.

This all started because of something that happened on Facebook. An acquaintance of mine who’s very pro-Hillary posted something about how scary it is that Jill Stein is “Anti-vaccine.” The post came with an article, which I read. In the article, Stein says nothing about vaccines being evil. What she said was that people have “A lot of questions about vaccines.” That’s definitely true. People do indeed have a lot of questions. Some of those questions are either stupid or unwarranted, but they’re questions nonetheless. What she said specifically about vaccines is that she has a problem with the FDA being so closely tied to the medical industry. The words straight from the candidate’s own mouth:


In reality, there is no anti-vaccine controversy here because Stein isn’t anti-vaccine. The next criticism is, well, that just plays into the conspiracy that Big Pharma really controls everything.

While that might be true, it’s also true that Stein’s position is all about social responsibility, and that extends to corporations. But being anti-corporate isn’t the same thing as being anti-vaccine, and it isn’t even the same thing as confirming or suggesting that the government and drug companies know that vaccines are bad and conspire together. But that fact is lost on the media, which only cares about ratings and clicks.

I considered unfollowing (not un-friending) this person on Facebook, but then I realized that she wasn’t the problem. It seemed like everything I was following in social media had something to say about politics. Even pages that have absolutely nothing to do with political issues seemed to throw their two cents in. So I made the step to give up social media until the election is over. After November, I’ll re-evaluate and determine if it’s worth going back.

But the experience made me realize just how detrimental the media is to our national political discourse. The media doesn’t report at all on Stein or Johnson, who in my mind are just as viable candidates as Trump or Clinton. But the media gets to control the narrative, to direct the conversation. And the direction they take the conversation frequently seems to be at odds with what would in my mind constitute a healthy political environment.

It used to be that the news just reported the objective facts. But we’ve all seen how over the decades, and especially in recent years, this has devolved into opinion and commentary as news. This devolution of course meant that things began to separate along party or ideological lines. Entities like Fox News and MSNBC cater exclusively to ideas that their viewers want to hear, not information that their viewers need to hear. And so we get conservative and liberal folks who live in bubbles where the facts that support the other side of the argument don’t exist, and everyone else is wrong. The echo chamber is created.

Go fuck yourself with a broomstick 

And social media only reinforces the echo chamber. It gives everyone a chance to repeat the talking points and the headlines, and the more people who do that, the more something like “Jill Stein is Anti-Vaccine” becomes a fact in the minds of many people. It gives people like Glenn Beck a chance to stir the pot and make opinion and drivel sound like news. I mean, honestly, who would argue that politic discourse wouldn’t be more productive and civil if the likes of Rush Limbaugh didn’t pollute the airwaves?

But the media loves shock jocks because they drive up the ratings, and more ratings means more money. Perhaps along with getting the money out of elections we should also get the money out of the news. As long as money is the prime motivation for reporting the news instead of informing, we’ll always get sensationalizing and editorials en lieu of actual facts and objective information.

Ultimately, though, this leaves me wondering how anyone is supposed to get legitimately objective information about politics in this country. I suppose you could limit yourself to what the candidates themselves say. Watch their conferences and rallies, read their press releases and websites, watch their interviews and ignore everything else. But the “everything else” is so pervasive and ubiquitous that seems like a huge task, especially if you’re not a person who’s adept at evaluating informational sources.

But something has to change, and it has to change soon. The media gave birth to Donald Trump by feeding that machine until it became a reality. Hopefully people will also rise up and take control of their media when they take back their elections.


8 thoughts on “The media is the problem

  1. Our entire system is screwed up. It really becomes more apparent when elections roll around.

    It is difficult for 3rd party candidates to gain any traction primarily because the media gives more attention to the “standard” 2 party system. Or the talking heads if they bother at all to discuss 3rd party candidates, it is only to denigrate them, or make jokes.

    Yes the system is the problem. The media, the corporations, the politicians, the government. Short of a miracle, or a truly independent 3rd party candidate with the means and the support system needed to get… Oh hell, nevermind it would take the miracle. Or a damn coup by the people, of the people, and for the people.

    We will be extinct as a species before it gets better.

    1. I’d like to think that everyone, every society, has a breaking point. I have no idea where America’s is. We don’t seem to be too concerned enough as a group to really care, or too lazy to actually do anything. I suppose there’s a danger in complacency, in growing too comfortable.

      1. Unfortunately a breaking point means enough people have to be willing to risk everything, even their lives, to enact change. All of a sudden I sound like I’m campaigning for a homegrown militia movement.

        Honestly I like my air conditioned house. My car. My family. My cable and internet. The flat screen etc. etc. etc.

        I am not willing or able to actually do anything to enact change right now. I will vote come Nov. And I’ll vote D across the board. Things just aren’t so bad to risk it all as our founders did to see that change take place. Although “President Trump” might be the kind of spark we’d need.

        The peaceful alternative is to vote wisely. Vote often. Support a viable 3rd party candidate when one rises to contention. I hope Bernie runs independent next time around.

  2. “But the media gets to control the narrative, to direct the conversation.”
    ~ When they don’t distort the truth, they simply neglect to report our reality on the ground. In so doing, they become accomplices in herding us like cattle to the slaughterhouse.

      1. Ryan, we need more political awareness and engagement; openness towards the other and their narratives. When I was growing up the communist was the demon to be feared, today it’s the Muslim. Who will it be tomorrow? The atheist?

      2. I hope it’s not the atheist or I’m screwed haha.

        I agree that we need more openness and political engagement, which why I find this particular topic so frustrating. Social media was supposed to help give the common man a voice, a platform, that would help inform and coordinate, inspire and create a new format of activism. The Arab Spring kind of fizzled out, but that’s a good example of the positive political capital of social media.

        Instead, we see the opposite of that happening in America. Social media is used to regurgitate the lies and fear mongering of the mainstream media.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s